Reggae Vibe Radio

Live from the studio

Queen of Dancehall Debate Reignites — Shenseea vs Spice After Catalyst Celebration

By Ras MahddyNovember 18, 2026 at 2:17 PMTrending

Shenseea has reignited the Queen of Dancehall debate after discussing her achievements and position during a recent interview in Florida at an event celebrating her Catalyst EP. The Jamaica Observer spoke to publicist Toni-Ann Kelly — who questioned whether streaming figures and international visibility are enough to decide the title — and communications professional Raymond "Shadow" Small. Shenseea stopped short of claiming the crown outright, but her remarks were enough to restart the conversation around Spice, the veteran widely regarded as holding it.

Queen of Dancehall Debate Reignites — Shenseea vs Spice After Catalyst Celebration featured image

(ReggaeVibeMedia.com) The Queen of Dancehall debate is back, and it is the liveliest fan argument in dancehall right now. Shenseea has sparked a fresh round of it after discussing her achievements and her position during a recent interview in Florida, at an event celebrating her latest EP, Catalyst.

The Jamaica Observer spoke to entertainment publicist Toni-Ann Kelly and communications professional Raymond "Shadow" Small about it. Kelly questioned whether streaming figures and international visibility are enough to decide who holds the title. Shenseea's remarks stopped short of claiming the crown outright — but they were enough to reignite the conversation around Spice, the veteran widely regarded as holding it.

This is not a new argument, and that is exactly why it never dies. Spice has carried the Queen of Dancehall title for years, earned across a career that made her the genre's most established female voice. Shenseea is the genre's biggest global female star right now — her Catalyst EP landed November 6 with eight tracks and features from Asake, Vybz Kartel and Loe Shimmy; the "Playtime" video with Asake was shot in London; the "Garden" visuals dropped November 12. She has spent the year stacking international firsts, including becoming the first Jamaican female artist to reach No. 1 on Billboard's Latin Airplay chart with "Echo," her FIFA World Cup 2026 collaboration with Daddy Yankee.

So the question the debate keeps asking is really two questions. Is the crown decided by the charts and the global reach, or by the years put in and the ground held at home? Kelly's point — that streaming numbers and international visibility might not be enough on their own — is the heart of it. Shenseea has not claimed the title. Spice has not had to defend it. And the fans, as always, will argue it out long after the interview clips stop circulating.

Share